Andy Murray vs Vasek Pospisil, Wednesday, Time - 1:00pm BST - Discuss the match
MurraysWorld  >  Chit Chat  >  Jews, who are they?
Pages: 1 ... 14 15 16 [17] Reply

Jews, who are they?

Quote

I thought it was fairly straightforward?
Clearly the Supreme Court disagrees!
IP Logged
Quote

This all sounds very messy ...
IP Logged
Quote

Clearly the Supreme Court disagrees!

I don't think you're correct, Mark, although it's not your fault for thinking that's what the Supreme Court are deciding.
The BBC article, particularly at the start is actually written extraordinarily badly! They write that the question put forward to the court is "Who is a Jew", and whether "practice" (i.e. religion) or "bloodline" (i.e. race) defines a Jew. That is not actually the case. Everyone agrees those are two possible meanings of being a "Jew". The question is just whether it's racially discriminating to have an acceptance policy to a Jewish school relying on the racial definition of a Jew.
On face value it seems to be discrimination, however the school's argument is that religious practice counts for nothing in Orthodox Judaism, and only your bloodline (or religious conversion) makes you Jewish, so their particular acceptance policy is not racist - if anything it's Orthodox Judaism's view which is racist.
IP Logged
Quote

That's ^ what I got out of the article ..... like I said, it all sounds very messy with possible spin-off problems in other faith schools. 

I have a friend in the US who is a practising Catholic, who has two little girls.  She sent both of them to the Jewish school because it was offering the best education around.
IP Logged
Quote

Which State/City was this in? And I'd bet it was a Reform Judaism school...
IP Logged
Quote

Pa.  No idea about the remainder of your remarks ...
IP Logged
Quote

Interesting. Didn't know there was a large enough Jewish community there to support a school...
IP Logged
Quote

I don't think you're correct, Mark, although it's not your fault for thinking that's what the Supreme Court are deciding.
Silly BBC Smile

I didn't read the article btw, just the start which clearly was the worst thing to read.
IP Logged
Quote

Apparently it is an outstanding school - someplace close to Harrisburg I'd think.  The little girls were also receiving Jewish Religious Instruction along with their classmates and learning lots of different aspects of the Jewish culture.  IMO - all to their benefit.  They have since moved and therefore changed school but have retained their friendships ...
IP Logged
Quote

I'm sorry to bring up this old thread but every time I see a guest browsing this, I can't help but laugh at the title. lol
IP Logged
Quote

Think
IP Logged
Quote

Sorry, looking for comic relief in any form while this forum is in a war.
IP Logged
Quote

Lets bring up random old threads from the good old days and bring this forum back to what it was.
IP Logged
Pages: 1 ... 14 15 16 [17] Reply