Thanks guys for the balanced views. I thought people might come back justifying their dislike for him, which used to happen.
I think they get on better now than in the early days. In fact I heard a rumour that Fed is the guest at the next Andy Murray Live.
Wow. Now that would be something because I didn't think I'd ever get the chance to see Fed play before he retired. It would be great if they could make that happen.
In fairness I did try some years ago to open a thread called Roger Federer Off-court, or something like that because I can't find any thread with that name now, because I couldn't believe he was all bad, but unfortunately it never really took off apart from being swamped by pics of Fed by a member who was also a massive fan of him as well as Andy.
That's a shame it never took off, Aileen. I think all players have different sides to them away from the court and we all know how much Andy is judged just by his on-court demeanour, which is only one small aspect of who he is.