Andy Murray vs Radek Stepanek, Today, Time - 7:00pm BST - Discuss the match
MurraysWorld  >  Sports Talk  >  BBC Sports Personality of the Year 2008
Poll
Who do you think should win?  (Voting closed: December 14, 2008, 07:29 PM)
Rebecca Adlington - 4 (20%)
Nicole Cooke - 0 (0%)
Chris Hoy - 10 (50%)
Bradley Wiggins - 0 (0%)
Rebecca Romero - 0 (0%)
Ben Ainslie - 1 (5%)
Christine Ohuruogu - 0 (0%)
Andy Murray - 3 (15%)
Lewis Hamilton - 2 (10%)
Joe Calzaghe - 0 (0%)
Total Voters: 20

Pages: 1 ... 5 6 7 [8] 9 10 Reply

BBC Sports Personality of the Year 2008

Quote

Fair enough but if you're going to go into numbers, it's actually 8 vs 3. Smile
(14 may be his total but I'm not sure medals won 4 years ago in Athens are relevant here)

But I also think the manner in which Bolt absolutey destroyed the 100m record, and beat the widely thought unbeatable 200m record is also worth something in addition to medals.
[ Last edit by invisibleman18 December 07, 2008, 10:36 PM ] IP Logged
Quote

My main reason for considering Bolt is because of that. That 200m run was staggering.
IP Logged
Quote

Phelps beat 7 world records and one olympic record.. maybe not in the same manner but it's still world records.

I'm not putting down Bolt's acheivements... he was incredible too but saying 3 gold medals deserves more acknowledgement than 8 medals in different strokes, to me, makes no sense.
IP Logged
Quote

I disagree. I'm not necessarily saying Bolt should win, but you definitely have to take into account the record broken, and how it was broken.
IP Logged
Quote

That's fair enough.
Not that it diminishes the achievements in any way, but for clarity it might also be noted that it wasn't actually 8 different strokes while 3 of his wins were also not individual ones.   
IP Logged
Quote

I am... it was phenominal. IMO the 100m was even better... the way he just walked accros the line was wow...

 But so is 8 golds and 7 records, swimming 17 races in 9 days... to be able to keep up that intensity through that whole time as well..
IP Logged
Quote


That's fair enough.
Not that it diminishes the achievements in any way, but for clarity it might also be noted that it wasn't actually 8 different strokes while 3 of his wins were also not individual ones.   


I realise that lol.. but he did swim all 4 strokes..
IP Logged
Quote

Indeed he did. Although 2 of them only in the medley. But again, that doesn't diminish things in any way. Smile
IP Logged
Quote

And at the end of the events he said that for the next games he was gonna try and do all events that he hadn't done before... (not that that really counts for SPOY but still)

This is an unresolvable argument lol... one that i spent much of my summer arguing Wink I guess we'll just see what happens next week. Though i think of the two the British public would go for Bolt, purely because athletics is more popular...
IP Logged
Quote

You have to remember they are in different sports. I think worldwide, Bolt will hold more acclaim than Phelps as indeed Athletics does more than Swimming.
IP Logged
Quote

Exactly. It's actually really hard to compare achievements when you're not comparing like for like. Swimmers have always won more events than athletes mainly because there are so many more events available to them that are similar enough such that the best ones are able to be the amongst best in each type. For someone like Usain Bolt, he can only do the 100m, 200m and the relay. Or rather he could only be any good in those ones. Sometimes sprinters do the long jump too although not very often. And the 2 that have been good at it in recent times have been drugs cheats anyway.

So who is to say x medals in swimming is better than y medals in athletics or the other way round? Who is to say Bolt wouldn't have also won the 100m, 200m and relay all running backwards or sideways or the 100m and 200m half backwards, half forwards like a medley? lol
There aren't enough similar events for an athlete to be able to win as many medals as a swimmer so maybe comparisons are not all that easy. Runners can usually do 2 or 3 events but for everyone else, there's only 1. In swimming, even your average no hoper (in terms of medals) could take part in 4 or 5.
IP Logged
Quote

^ yeah, good point.. Either of the two would be deserving.
IP Logged
Quote

So it begins, Tim is sitting next to Kelly! lol

Sue just gave Tim the wimbledon trophy lmao
IP Logged
Quote

And the Young Sports Personality of the year goes to! - Eleanor Symmonds!

Certainly between her and Robson, well deserved though Smile  clap
IP Logged
Quote

I thought Laura would of won that
IP Logged
Pages: 1 ... 5 6 7 [8] 9 10 Reply