I find that when the moderators make a decision that is highly controversial, and one that is not a judgement of a individual's future, it's better to take it out of the hands of the mods and bring it to a public vote. That will generally put a halt to constant complaining from those that do not agree with the decision.
Maybe but in this case certain individuals had an agenda beyond this daft video (imho). They didn't like the fact some of us staunch Andy fans are also Rafa fans and they wanted to make lots of trouble. The mods had to stem it. I thought they were rather reasonable. It's not like discussion stopped.